The Importance of Personality and Customer Service in Bartending

Countless bars have found success by fostering a culture that celebrates their bartenders as personalities, not just service staff.

Take a look at the internationally acclaimed “Dead Rabbit” in New York City, for example. 

Although renowned for its exceptional cocktails, the bar is equally celebrated for its charismatic bartenders, who are seen not just as service staff but as central figures in the bar’s identity.

Jillian Vose, the beverage director at Dead Rabbit, said the essence of her bar’s success primarily lies in the bartenders’ personalities, as well as their understanding of the craft and the ability to empathize with guests.

She describes her bar as a place where everyone is a character in their own right, where camaraderie is palpable, and where every team member is committed to excellence.

And we agree – which is why we’re using this article to dive deeper into the world of bartending and explore the vital role of personality and customer service in creating unforgettable bar experiences. 

So, if you want to learn what sets good bartenders apart from truly great ones, join us along the ride!

The Power of Personality in Bartending

Ever walk into a bar feeling like a lone tumbleweed in a ghost town?  Yeah, not exactly a vibe. 

But then, a bartender with a smile that could melt glaciers greets you by name (or at least makes you feel like they will soon). Suddenly, that dive bar feels a little less divey and a whole lot more welcoming.

That’s the power of personality behind the bar. 

You see, when people hear the phrase “a great bartender,” they never think of someone who’s just a great drink pourer. 

They think of someone who’s a great listener, has a friendly face, and is a master of creating memorable experiences. They think of a person who can read the room, anticipate needs, and bring a touch of magic to every interaction. 

So, if you’re looking to become a bartender, forget the service staff role. Your true role will lie in being an actual experience creator. 

You’ll craft personalized moments that turn a bar from a pit stop for a drink into a haven of comfort and connection.  

That’s, of course, if you want to keep your customers coming back for more. 

5 Key Personality Traits of a Bartender

Choosing just five key personality traits of an exceptional bartender was no easy feat, but someone had to do it.

Here are our top 5 picks:

Warmth and Friendliness

“The sunshine behind the bar” – that’s the nickname we gave to our favorite bartender at the corner bar. 

Her welcoming smile and genuine conversation put everyone at ease, including us. Beyond that, she had a knack for making customers feel comfortable with a simple “What can I get you today?”. This earned her tons of loyalty from customers, translating into bigger tips and lots of positive word-of-mouth for the bar. 

So, if you’re wondering what warmth and friendliness get you as a bartender, it’s a dedicated following and a reputation that goes beyond just serving drinks, to begin with.

Active Listening and Empathy

Great bartenders rarely fail to pick up on customer cues and emotions. They can sense when someone needs a listening ear or just a quick drink and a smile. 

Just put yourself in a situation where you’ve come into a bar after experiencing an unpleasant life event, and a bartender addresses you by your name, asking “Rough day, huh?”.

Wouldn’t that make you feel seen and cared for? 

It’s these small, personal touches that can turn a bad day around and make a lasting impression. They’re what builds rapport, fosters trust, and creates a sense of community within the bar.

Adaptability and Patience

A friend’s father always used to say, “A bar can be a microcosm of the world, with customers of all walks of life and moods.”

And boy, was he right!

One thing we’ve learned is that a good bartender can navigate these differences with grace, and is usually exceptional at diffusing tension while ensuring everyone in the bar feels comfortable.  

And isn’t that what we all want when we walk into a bar? 

A place where we can relax, unwind, and feel at home, no matter what’s happening outside. 

Enthusiasm and Passion

Everyone loves a bartender who’s genuinely into their craft. That kind of excitement is contagious and is sought after in every bartender job description.

For instance, if you were a lover of unique cocktails and had a bartender come up to you to explain the unique ingredients and inspiration behind his latest creation, wouldn’t that make your experience so much more enjoyable? 

Wouldn’t that leave you eager to return for more?

Exceptional bartenders know how to use their enthusiasm and passion to increase customer engagement while simultaneously elevating the perception of the bar they’re working in.

Humor and Wit

Who doesn’t like a well-timed joke or playful banter?

Of course, using humor requires good judgment and reading the room, and that’s what exceptional bartenders are known for.

They are masters of playful interactions, which not only strengthen the customer-bartender bond but also make the bar a more enjoyable place to socialize.

It’s a win-win for everyone involved.

Customer Service Excellence in Bartending

The foundation of exceptional bartending lies in knowing two things:

  • What your customers need; and
  • What your customers expect.

When a bartender can anticipate these two things, they can provide a level of service that goes beyond just serving drinks. 

Although being friendly and attentive are important traits to have as a bartender, what’s more important is having the ability to read the room, understand the individual preferences of your customers, and adapt your service accordingly.

Think about it—imagine a customer celebrating a special occasion and receiving a complimentary drink or a personalized cocktail to enhance the moment. Or picture a customer seeking a quiet spot to unwind after a long day, and the bartender suggesting a cozy corner for them to relax in.

It’s these thoughtful gestures that elevate the customer experience and foster loyalty. And these gestures are rooted in principles that aren’t arbitrary.

These principles are rooted in the essence of exceptional bartending, and they embody the 5 key traits we’ve discussed because they form the backbone of customer service excellence. 

See how everything ties together?


If you’re going to take away one thing from this article, let it be this: 

A smile, a kind word, and a genuine interest in your customers can turn an ordinary bar into a place where people forge lasting memories and find a sense of community they long for.

Now go on and use those bartending skills of yours for good!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *